About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

U.S. Coins for Sale/Bid

Greysheet Marketplace: Nickels, Buffalo Nickels (1913–1938)

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

cac.png
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS67+ CAC
eye-icon 9
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/5/2025
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS67
eye-icon 28
Seller - DLRC
$ 901.88
Buy It Now
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c NGC MS66
eye-icon 8
Seller - Heritage Auctions
185.00
Auction Ends 9/16/2025
Ad Banner
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS66
eye-icon 13
Seller - DLRC
$ 439.38
Buy It Now
cac.png
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS65 CAC
eye-icon 10
Seller - Heritage Auctions
150.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1913 Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS65
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 208.13
Buy It Now
1913-D Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS67
eye-icon 11
Seller - Common Cents Rare Coins
$ 1,650.00
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1913-D Buffalo, Type 1 5c NGC MS67
eye-icon 311
Seller - Heritage Coin Wholesale
$ 1,600.00
Buy It Now
1913-S Buffalo, Type 1 5c NGC MS66
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 1,110.00
Buy It Now
cac.png
1913-S Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS64 CAC
eye-icon 11
Seller - Heritage Auctions
343.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1913-S Buffalo, Type 1 5c PCGS MS63
eye-icon 13
Seller - DLRC
$ 300.63
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1913 Buffalo, Type 2 5c PCGS MS67
eye-icon 10
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/2/2025
1913-D Buffalo, Type 2 5c PCGS XF45
eye-icon 17
Seller - DLRC
$ 185.00
Buy It Now
1913-D Buffalo, Type 2 5c PCGS VG8
eye-icon 11
Seller - DLRC
$ 161.88
Buy It Now
1913-S Buffalo, Type 2 5c PCGS MS65
eye-icon 10
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/5/2025
Ad Banner
1913-S Buffalo, Type 2 5c PCGS VF30
eye-icon 11
Seller - DLRC
$ 416.25
Buy It Now
cac.png
1914 5c PCGS MS67 CAC
eye-icon 14
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/2/2025
1914-D 5c PCGS VF30
eye-icon 13
Seller - DLRC
$ 185.00
Buy It Now
cac.png
1914-S 5c PCGS MS66+ CAC
eye-icon 11
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/2/2025
Ad Banner
1914-S 5c PCGS MS64
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 1,295.00
Buy It Now
1915-D 5c PCGS AU55
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 231.25
Buy It Now
1915-D 5c NGC VF20
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 69.38
Buy It Now
1916 5c PCGS MS65
eye-icon 15
Seller - DLRC
$ 370.00
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1917 5c NGC MS65
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 485.63
Buy It Now
1918-D 5c PCGS VF20
eye-icon 10
Seller - DLRC
$ 129.50
Buy It Now
1918-D 5c PCGS F12
eye-icon 14
Seller - DLRC
$ 74.00
Buy It Now
1918/7-D 5c PCGS F12
eye-icon 13
Seller - DLRC
$ 2,312.50
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
Image
Coming
Soon
1918/7-D Overdate, FS-101 5c NGC F15
Seller - Heritage Auctions
55.00
Auction Ends 9/29/2025
1918-S 5c PCGS AU58
eye-icon 12
Seller - DLRC
$ 786.25
Buy It Now
1919 5c PCGS MS67
eye-icon 19
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/2/2025
1919 5c PCGS MS67
eye-icon 15
Seller - DLRC
$ 4,208.75
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
cac.png
1919 5c PCGS MS66+ CAC
eye-icon 13
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/5/2025
1919 5c PCGS MS64
eye-icon 14
Seller - DLRC
$ 346.88
Buy It Now
1919-D 5c NGC AU58
eye-icon 10
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 9/29/2025
1919-D 5c PCGS VF30
eye-icon 15
Seller - DLRC
$ 161.88
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1919-D 5c PCGS F15
eye-icon 13
Seller - DLRC
$ 101.75
Buy It Now
1 2 ... 4