About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

U.S. Coins for Sale/Bid

Greysheet Marketplace: Nickels, Shield Nickels Proof (1866–1883)

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

1867 No Rays 5c NGC PR65 DCAM
eye-icon 14
Seller - Charleston Rare Coins
$ 7,500.00
Buy It Now
1873 Closed 3 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
eye-icon 23
Seller - Charleston Rare Coins
$ 8,400.00
Buy It Now
1874 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 49
Seller - DLRC
$ 3,006.25
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1874 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
eye-icon 47
Seller - DLRC
$ 7,215.00
Buy It Now
1875 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 15
Seller - DLRC
$ 6,937.50
Buy It Now
1876 5c PCGS PR63
eye-icon 14
Seller - Heritage Auctions
310.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1876 5c PCGS PR66 CAM
eye-icon 14
Seller - DLRC
$ 1,850.00
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
cac.png
1877 5c PCGS PR66 CAM CAC
eye-icon 13
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 10/2/2025
1877 5c PCGS PR66 CAM
eye-icon 18
Seller - DLRC
$ 5,873.75
Buy It Now
cac.png
1878 5c PCGS PR64 CAC
eye-icon 14
Seller - Heritage Auctions
925.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1879/8 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 16
Seller - DLRC
$ 2,867.50
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1880 5c PCGS PR66
eye-icon 16
Seller - DLRC
$ 901.88
Buy It Now
1881 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 46
Seller - DLRC
$ 2,566.88
Buy It Now
1881 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
eye-icon 53
Seller - DLRC
$ 5,411.25
Buy It Now
1882 5c PCGS PR66 CAM
eye-icon 21
Seller - DLRC
$ 832.50
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1883 Shield 5c PCGS PR66
eye-icon 28
Seller - Charleston Rare Coins
$ 735.00
Buy It Now
Image
Coming
Soon
1883 Shield 5c NGC PR65
eye-icon 6
Seller - Heritage Auctions
400.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1883 Shield 5c PCGS PR65
eye-icon 18
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 9/15/2025
1883 Shield 5c NGC PR64
eye-icon 13
Seller - Heritage Auctions
1.00
Auction Ends 9/16/2025
Ad Banner
1